I would separate being a great singer from having a great voice.
---------- Post added at 08:44 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:46 AM ----------
And while I can break down everything in the music world based simply on my own personal preferences, some musicians are simply better at their trade than others. They are better players, writers, singers...etc. They have better ears. Basically, it comes down to who has better control over the music they make. The better you are, the more options you have as a player and a writer (rather than just sitting down with your guitar and playing either the few chords you know in different orders or random shapes until you get something that sounds good), the more in control of your music you are. For the record, anyone can sit at a piano and mess around til they get something that sounds good. Plugging the shit into a computer makes it 8 million times easier to end up making a song. Why do you think there are so many one hit wonders in the pop and electronic world? Because the people who make them basically don't know how to do it again. Basically, because they aren't good musicians, but they made a nice song. That is the reality.
It is a much more powerful statement when a master musician can say "yes, I could play whatever I want to, but I CHOOSE to play this." Justin Beiber can in absolutely no way play whatever he wants to. This is because he is a WORSE musician. If you like his music, then fine. It doesn't make him a better musician. And, in reality, how can you say that your music is truly yours until you can say you have considered all the options. Until then, it is only partly yours. The rest is a product of your limitations and outside influences.
It is also absolutely ignorant of people to think that musicians have music in their ear from the time they are born and they just spend their life trying to figure out how to play it. No. You TRAIN your ear. It changes. You start to be able to tell the difference between closer notes and notice melodies. Little melodic phrases are like words. Little rhythmic cliches are the same way. It gets to the point where you just hear a melody and you hear the whole, not the parts. Take "nanny nanny boo boo" for instance. I could play that little cliche all over the place in a chord, but you would still hear the nanny's and the boo boo's. So the music one makes will inevitably change as they become a better musician.
---------- Post added at 05:45 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:44 AM ----------
I write books.