I voted moment because he's always on when I'm on and always answers any requests from the shout. He also does so much work for recruitment. I've also seen him kind of mature as a moderator a LOT recently.
Animal definitely would have gotten my vote otherwise. He's on when most of us are not. This is a very important thing. And man... he's just the opposite of an attention whore. He uses up like 0 krew resources. And still, is a very reserved, effective moderator. Not hasty or rash. Just completely dependable.
I play server 1 a lot and nate is almost always on when I am. The dude plays a lot. So he knows the server. He knows all the people. He knows when someone is new. totally exactly what is good in moderators here.
I just wanna say all 3 of your are doing an excellent job in my eyes and when I'm playing.
Just my 2 cents.